JStew vs. Beanie - Forums

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Login with Facebook Sign In with Google Sign In with OpenID Sign In with Twitter
Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion

Top Posters

Who's Online (9)

Homepage | Articles | Rankings | Projections | Upside Board | Calcs | Forums | Terms | FAQs - [ Start a New Discussion ]
JStew vs. Beanie
  • ffbfan06ffbfan06
    Posts: 532
    Beanie quietly had 1047 yds rushing and 10 tds last year.  JStew has elite talent and a poor situation.  Talent doesn't change as much as situations can.  Do you make the move straight up, or what is the value difference?
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,022
    Talent wise I definitely like Stew but I have to go with Beanie here until I see Stew's situation improve...which might never happen.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • _X__X_
    Posts: 414
    The only reason you could land Stewart with a guy like Beanie right now is situation, if Stewart was ever to land a gig as starter he'd have top10 RB value immediately.  If you think that will happen in the next few years, it is worth considering.  If I had a team where Beanie was expendable, I'd consider taking that shot, otherwise it would be tough to justify selling a decent RB2 to land Stewart.
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,022
    Thats what I was thinking. He would have to be like your 3rd or 4th RB.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • rabidbucfanrabidbucfan
    Posts: 2,537
    +1 for _X_ and JR
    most peoples lives are a direct reflection of the expectations of those around you

    what if you have a higher expectation for yourself than those you associate with?
  • bddavidsonbddavidson
    Posts: 7,010
    like both these guys.. but beanie is a starter at this point.. Who knows if stewart ever gets his shot? we have been think this for years now.. leave up the panthers to screw with us FF people...If the cards will improve there O-line beanie will become better..that O-line is one of the worst in football.but sewart is more talented..
    DC Nation Moderator
  • ReisssoxReisssox
    Posts: 2,303
    If Stew could get a gig, we would never have this talk...Till then, Baby beanie is the guy...At least for now... :-SS
  • ffbfan06ffbfan06
    Posts: 532
    PPR. I have McCoy, Forte, Sproles, and Beanie as my top four. Other than bye week or injuries, Beanie won't start for me. JStew in the right situation would make my starters Shady, Forte, and JStew. Big IF on the right situation though.
  • bddavidsonbddavidson
    Posts: 7,010
    if your willing to gamble on sewart leaving then it is decent value but i ask for a pick as well..
    DC Nation Moderator
  • ArtySArtyS
    Posts: 1,238
    Even with Stewarts situation I would still prefer him to Beanie
  • Whos_Ur_DoggieWhos_Ur_Doggie
    Posts: 7,959
    ArtyS said:

    Even with Stewarts situation I would still prefer him to Beanie



    +1 I agree.
    DC Nation Moderator
Add a Comment