Sidney rice or Crabtree

andr3wl

Who do you prefer as your wr3/4 in a ppr and why?

haimez40

I actually think Crabtree turned a corner last year and he could really break out this. I like Crabtree. I go to the SF vs STL game every year and Crabtree this year was noticibly in better shape, even my 9 year old noticed it. I think he had a little of the entitlement/diva syndrome at first and now is working hard at getting better.

Sidney Rice has great talent and could bounce back to elite, but I'm nervous about injuries. Sure it could be flukish type stuff right now, but he isn't having little injuries that go away. I'm afraid it could be a trend. If healthy he is probably better cause his seperation skills, but my gut goes with Crabtree.

RIPPERS

Sidney Rice would be my choice. The Seahawks may surprise some this year. Its going to be interesting to see what they do in the draft. Leave Crabtree on the table for somebody else.

BuckysGT

I would go with Crabtree. Rice's injuries scare me.

JRMRRT

Neither...Crabtree I guess until I see Rice healthy. Rice is more talented though IMO.

bddavidson

Rice...aleast he has produced when having a decent qb and healthy crabs not so much..

ArtyS

I think Rice has more upside if healthy but I would probably take Crabtree because Rice is always injured

Whos_Ur_Doggie

Rice....... I have zero interest in Crabtree.

RIPPERS

JRMRRT said:
Neither...Crabtree I guess until I see Rice healthy. Rice is more talented though IMO.

You would rather have Crabs? =))

fontaines

RIPPERS said:

JRMRRT said:
Neither...Crabtree I guess until I see Rice healthy. Rice is more talented though IMO.

You would rather have Crabs? =))

I would too. Rice was quite money motivated too. At least Crabs needs to eventually play for a new contract. But ultimately, I could probably find a Free agent in most leagues that I'd rather roster than either of these guys

RIPPERS

fontaines said:

RIPPERS said:

JRMRRT said:
Neither...Crabtree I guess until I see Rice healthy. Rice is more talented though IMO.

You would rather have Crabs? =))

I would too. Rice was quite money motivated too. At least Crabs needs to eventually play for a new contract. But ultimately, I could probably find a Free agent in most leagues that I'd rather roster than either of these guys

Crabs is just itching to play for a contract =))

JRMRRT

RIPPERS said:

JRMRRT said:
Neither...Crabtree I guess until I see Rice healthy. Rice is more talented though IMO.

You would rather have Crabs? =))

I believe Mr. Rippers is referring to the little critters that live on the nasty peoples genitalia...ha.....ha.....ha... :-L...Do we have a kiddy table here at the Nation?

L-) :D..........MEATHEAD!

Reisssox

Oh boy....he has been sniffing glue against

JRMRRT

Against what? :-B

tmoney

C. None of the above.

In fact I have Rice on one team, and I can't get anything for him.

RIPPERS

Are we not allowed to have fun here? OK all seriousness aside.

JRMRRT

RIPPERS said:
Are we not allowed to have fun here?

Everyone but you...

rabidbucfan

LOL that's good stuff - Crabs for me please hold the Rice

JRMRRT

Yeah, Ill have crabs and rice rolled up and dipped in a little soy sauce and wasabe.

tmoney

After his next concussion, Sidney is going to change his name to Vegetable Rice.

JRMRRT

After his next concussion, Sidney is going to change his name to Vegetable Rice.

Then he will start smoking weed and be, Vegetable Fried Rice... 8-}

DraftCalc Now Has LIVE Mock Drafting

Howdy, Stranger!

Categories

In this Discussion

Top Posters

Who's Online (15)

DraftCalc Now Has **LIVE** Mock Drafting