• pemo August 14

  Posts: 870

  I need some advice in a start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex 10 team PPR dynasty league.  I want to mention that I personally value AJG more than Trent Richardson, I think AJG is truly special.  I don't care how deep WR is when I have one that will give me a fantastic chance at top 5 production for the next 6 years.

  
  

  M Stafford

  
  

  M Forte, C Johnson, D Wilson, B Pierce, J Stewart, A Brown,

  
  

  AJ Green, R Cobb, H Nicks, K Britt, D Hopkins, R Randle, J Gordon, Micheal Floyd

  
  

  R Gronkowski, Z Ertz, R Housler

  
  

  I'm thinking of offering AJ Green for TRich, Givens, and a 2014 first round pick.  I think I can make it happen, considering how big of a fan the guy is of AJG.  The only hitch is I will have to drop one of the players above to make room for givens.

  
  

  Thoughts?

  
  

   

  Predictions
  
  [ ] Percy Harvin will be a top 5 PPR wide receiver, outscoring Cobb
  [ ] Danny Amendola will be a top 15 PPR wide receiver
  [ ] Russel Wilson will be a top 4 QB
  [ ] Denario Alexander will be a top 15 PPR WR
• k0wned August 14

  Posts: 206

  For me Trent > AJ. I'd do it and drop Ertz or Brown. 
• popo24 August 14

  Posts: 768

  I took AJ. I think his top 5 production is more like top 3 and lasts more like 8-10 years.

  
  
• pemo August 14

  Posts: 870

  popo24 said:

  I took AJ. I think his top 5 production is more like top 3 and lasts more like 8-10 years.

  
  
  Ya, this is where I'm leaning.  I don't know if I will like this deal too much in 2 years - I don't know how I feel about it right now.  Givens is great, but that offense is going to spread the ball around, so I think mid to low WR2 is his ceiling, and I don't feel great about him hitting that ceiling.

  Predictions
  
  [ ] Percy Harvin will be a top 5 PPR wide receiver, outscoring Cobb
  [ ] Danny Amendola will be a top 15 PPR wide receiver
  [ ] Russel Wilson will be a top 4 QB
  [ ] Denario Alexander will be a top 15 PPR WR
• fontaines August 14

  Posts: 3,713

  i don't think you can afford to downgrade your wrs.  Your rbs are actually decent i'd stay put

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• JRMRRT August 14

  Posts: 10,774

  pemo said:

   I want to mention that I personally value AJG more than Trent Richardson, I think AJG is truly special. Thoughts?

  
  

   

  
  
  If you really feel this way Im not sure why you would want to make this deal. Givens and a pick would not be enough for me to give up value and an elite young player I covet. That said I like T Rich slightly more so I would do this if it were me.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• superman81284 August 14

  Posts: 189

  AJG will have a longer career than trich will...

  Qb: R.Wilson
  Rb: D.Wilson, A.Brown, D.Rich, M.Leshoure, M.Reece
  Wr: AJGreen, J.Jones, J.Edelman
  Te: Pitta
  1.08, 1.12, 2.05, 2.12 (20 man dynasty)
• JRMRRT August 14

  Posts: 10,774

  superman81284 said:

  AJG will have a longer career than trich will...

  
  
  But T Rich has like 8 years to go. Its ridiculous to think that far out or even past 3 years IMO. They are both elite young studs.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• pemo August 14

  Posts: 870

  JRMRRT said:

  superman81284 said:

  AJG will have a longer career than trich will...

  
  
  But T Rich has like 8 years to go. Its ridiculous to think that far out or even past 3 years IMO. They are both elite young studs.

  
  
  
  

  I don't feel too comfortable with assuming TRich will last till he's 30

  Predictions
  
  [ ] Percy Harvin will be a top 5 PPR wide receiver, outscoring Cobb
  [ ] Danny Amendola will be a top 15 PPR wide receiver
  [ ] Russel Wilson will be a top 4 QB
  [ ] Denario Alexander will be a top 15 PPR WR
• JRMRRT August 14

  Posts: 10,774

  AJ Green could blow his knee out tomorrow and have chronic issues the rest of his career. AP just rushed for over 2000 yards coming off knee reconstruction and Charles rushed for 1500. Kenny Britt is still not recovered from his 2 years ago. Ranking players that are this young based on how long their careers will be is just nuts to me. 

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• pemo August 14

  Posts: 870

  JRMRRT said:

  AJ Green could blow his knee out tomorrow and have chronic issues the rest of his career. AP just rushed for over 2000 yards coming off knee reconstruction and Charles rushed for 1500. Kenny Britt is still not recovered from his 2 years ago. Ranking players that are this young based on how long their careers will be is just nuts to me. 

  
  
  I'm playing the probability game.  Anything could happen, but arguing that AJ Green doesn't have a higher probability to have a longer career is silly.  The evidence doesn't point that way.

  
  

  
  

  Predictions
  
  [ ] Percy Harvin will be a top 5 PPR wide receiver, outscoring Cobb
  [ ] Danny Amendola will be a top 15 PPR wide receiver
  [ ] Russel Wilson will be a top 4 QB
  [ ] Denario Alexander will be a top 15 PPR WR
• zeeshan2 August 14

  Posts: 1,118

  WR's have a longer shelf life than RB's
• JRMRRT August 14

  Posts: 10,774

  pemo said:

  JRMRRT said:

  AJ Green could blow his knee out tomorrow and have chronic issues the rest of his career. AP just rushed for over 2000 yards coming off knee reconstruction and Charles rushed for 1500. Kenny Britt is still not recovered from his 2 years ago. Ranking players that are this young based on how long their careers will be is just nuts to me. 

  
  
  I'm playing the probability game.  Anything could happen, but arguing that AJ Green doesn't have a higher probability to have a longer career is silly.  The evidence doesn't point that way.

  
  

  
  

  
  
  And I think its just silly to worry about the length of T Rich's career when he just turned 22.  

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• superman81284 August 14

  Posts: 189

  zeeshan2 said:

  WR's have a longer shelf life than RB's

  
  
  This is what I meant...
  
  Trich is only entering his second year and already has durability issues... Plus is running style is to punish...
  

  Qb: R.Wilson
  Rb: D.Wilson, A.Brown, D.Rich, M.Leshoure, M.Reece
  Wr: AJGreen, J.Jones, J.Edelman
  Te: Pitta
  1.08, 1.12, 2.05, 2.12 (20 man dynasty)

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft