Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion

  • ArtyS February 7
  • BK19 February 7
  • dunlap13 February 7
  • emurrell17 February 7
  • fontaines February 7
  • jbcalc February 7
  • Reisssox February 7
  • stewss7 February 7
  • Whos_Ur_Doggie February 7

Top Posters

  • Whos_Ur_Doggie 12566
  • bddavidson 12134
  • JRMRRT 11076
  • Wutthecrapman 9966
  • BuckysGT 7661
  • LukeB5301 7413
  • garyzab 7109
  • Smitty 6990
  • TBL 4690
  • fontaines 4405
  • branch0095 4332

Who's Online (7)

  • Dcaster 11:42AM
  • Dynomite 11:42AM
  • fjh1379 11:39AM
  • fontaines 11:42AM
  • haimez40 11:39AM
  • nevilleknows 11:40AM
  • Whos_Ur_Doggie 11:40AM
Homepage | Ranks | Projections | Articles | Upside Board | FAQs | Forums - [ Start A New Discussion ]
Need a forum Invite?
  • Dynasty Only!!!
McCoy/Sproles or Reggie/Harvin/Crabtree
  • k0wnedk0wned
    Posts: 333
    Which side do you like?
    Trade
    1. Which side is worth more?15 votes
      1. McCoy and Sproles
        60.00%
      2. Reggie Bush, Harvin, and Crabtree
        40.00%
  • Whos_Ur_DoggieWhos_Ur_Doggie February 7
    Posts: 12,566
    The value is with Bush, Harvin and Crabtree.  The best player is McCoy IMO.  This would really depend on your roster but I almost always lean on the side with the best player.   ;)
    DC Nation Moderator
  • BK19BK19 February 7
    Posts: 45
    McCoy is the best player but I'd personally take Reggie, Percy, and Crabtree
  • fontainesfontaines February 7
    Posts: 4,405
    I'll take the best player in the deal.

    I'm assuming a team that can afford to lose Reggie, Harvin and Crabs has decent depth and can afford this move.  Even without, it's tough to get dynasty's #1 RB and it's nice to get a player like Mccoy without giving up a top 20 player yourself
    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • ArtySArtyS February 7
    Posts: 1,415
    McCoy side
  • jbcalcjbcalc February 7
    Posts: 9
    The hardest part of getting a top dynasty stud like McCoy is having an owner willing to even trade him.  I honestly don't think this is an overpay, but even if you valued it as a slight overpay, it's the premium you have to pay to get that type of player.
  • stewss7stewss7 February 7
    Posts: 688
    McCoy side by a mile.
    @stewss7
  • dunlap13dunlap13 February 7
    Posts: 1,789
    Percy crabs and reggie.

    Could easily flip reggie for an up and comer like bell.
    .5 ppr 10 Team Dynasty: 1 Qb, 2 Rb, 3 Wr, 1 Rb/Wr, 1 Te

    Peyton Manning

    CJ Spiller, Leveon Bell, Demarco Murray, Shane Vereen, Lamar Miller, Bernard Peirce, Christine Michael Johnathan Franklin

    Dez Bryant, Josh Gordon, Randall Cobb, Alshon Jeffery, Jarrett Boykin

    Kyle Rudolph, Martellus Bennett

    1.4 1.10 2.10 3.10
  • Reisssox February 7
    Posts: 3,128
    dunlap13 said:

    Percy crabs and reggie.

    Could easily flip reggie for an up and comer like bell.


    What? No way anyone gives you Bell for Wayne?

  • stewss7stewss7 February 7
    Posts: 688
    Not me
    @stewss7
  • emurrell17 February 7
    Posts: 2,919
    Reisssox said:

    dunlap13 said:

    Percy crabs and reggie.

    Could easily flip reggie for an up and comer like bell.


    What? No way anyone gives you Bell for Wayne?



    Is this a joke?


    I think the value is with Reggie side without a doubt. However- it is a pretty realistic possibility that a situation could present itself that would make the McCoy side more valuable. If it's a small league (8-10 teams) then I'd take McCoy. If it's anything bigger than that, or expanded starting rosters id take the Harvin side in a heartbeat.

    Strictly value wise I believe it's the crabs side, but depending on situation, I could be easily persuaded otherwise
    Bold Predictions:
    June 21- Dez Bryant finishes as the #1 WR in 2013.
Add a Comment