It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
donvaughn said:Redraft or dynasty?
Wutthecrapman said:If he continues performing he's easily top 10. I still have to respect the guys before him before I give him top 5 rankings. Guys like A-Rod, Stafford, Brees, Luck, Newton, and even Peyton.
I just don't want a fall from grace like we seen with Derek Anderson.
bmxholden1 said:Not sure where I rank him but let me add this, without the Oakland game his per-game average puts him right at Russell Wilson level - about 8-10. So throw away the anomaly game and he will need to improve to get to elite. Not saying he won't, but just knowing he must outperform his great run makes me put him in 5-7 as a best case, and often players have Sophomore slumps so I'm going with 7th factoring it all together.
FYI - Wilson jumps to top 6 this year getting back his WR's, his TE and his 2 Pro Bowl O'Linemen
pld66 said:
bmxholden1 said:Not sure where I rank him but let me add this, without the Oakland game his per-game average puts him right at Russell Wilson level - about 8-10. So throw away the anomaly game and he will need to improve to get to elite. Not saying he won't, but just knowing he must outperform his great run makes me put him in 5-7 as a best case, and often players have Sophomore slumps so I'm going with 7th factoring it all together.
FYI - Wilson jumps to top 6 this year getting back his WR's, his TE and his 2 Pro Bowl O'Linemen
Yeah sure take out his best game (45 Points) and grade him on a curve to make your point.......So take out Wilsons best game (29 points) and he averages 18.45 on MFL scoring and take out Foles best game and he averages 22.06 so he is around 4 points better per game not really the same level.
And for QB's on the same level explain this stat. Number of games scoring 20+ points
Foles 7 out of 10 games
Wilson 6 out of 15 games
Yeah try trading Wilson for Foles straight up and tellme how that goes.....or show me any start up draft where Wilson is drafted ahead of Foles. Do that and you may have a point..............
BTW I like Wilson but he is not on Foles Level.
HailMary said:pld66 said:
bmxholden1 said:Not sure where I rank him but let me add this, without the Oakland game his per-game average puts him right at Russell Wilson level - about 8-10. So throw away the anomaly game and he will need to improve to get to elite. Not saying he won't, but just knowing he must outperform his great run makes me put him in 5-7 as a best case, and often players have Sophomore slumps so I'm going with 7th factoring it all together.
FYI - Wilson jumps to top 6 this year getting back his WR's, his TE and his 2 Pro Bowl O'Linemen
Yeah sure take out his best game (45 Points) and grade him on a curve to make your point.......So take out Wilsons best game (29 points) and he averages 18.45 on MFL scoring and take out Foles best game and he averages 22.06 so he is around 4 points better per game not really the same level.
And for QB's on the same level explain this stat. Number of games scoring 20+ points
Foles 7 out of 10 games
Wilson 6 out of 15 games
Yeah try trading Wilson for Foles straight up and tellme how that goes.....or show me any start up draft where Wilson is drafted ahead of Foles. Do that and you may have a point..............
BTW I like Wilson but he is not on Foles Level.
thanks. I didn't have the energy to refute it. Lol
View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft | DC BBall Keeper Lg