fantasy football forums

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion

  • bmxholden1 June 25
  • chuckeycharles June 26
  • donvaughn June 25
  • GoWithWhatYouGot June 25
  • LukeB5301 June 25
  • rabidbucfan June 26
  • sbarone June 25
  • Shmily June 25
  • Smitty June 25
  • SweetLew June 25
  • Troy_Polamalyourass June 25
  • wh0urdady June 25
  • Wutthecrapman June 25
  • Xtreme June 25

Top Posters

  • bddavidson 13988
  • Whos_Ur_Doggie 13665
  • JRMRRT 13543
  • Wutthecrapman 10725
  • LukeB5301 8924
  • Smitty 8639
  • BuckysGT 8275
  • garyzab 7118
  • branch0095 5553
  • TBL 5415
  • fontaines 5323

Who's Online (8)

  • dunlap13 7:42AM
  • Fitzismyguy 7:40AM
  • footballjunkie 7:39AM
  • george 7:42AM
  • N_Diddy 7:40AM
  • omahabrad 7:41AM
  • Swampies 7:40AM
  • Xtreme 7:42AM

If you are already a DraftCalc Subscriber, hang tight in terms of getting access to FFStarters content... that is in the works. We will keep you posted shortly!

Our Breaking News Wire is up!

Homepage | Ranks | News | Projections | Articles | Sims | Calcs | Upside Board | FAQs | Forums - [ Start A New Discussion ]
Need a forum Invite?
NEWS: Toby Gerhart being talked about around the NFL?
  • chuckeycharles June 25
    Posts: 2,417
    I picked him up from the trash heap after he was signed by Jax

    He won't cost more than an 8th round pick in my keeper league, maybe later 
    ---- Both Leagues - Start QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - K - DST - All TD = 6 / Pass Yd = .04 / Rush-Rec Yd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonuses ----
    ---- 10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3) QB - NONE / RB - L.Bell, D.Martin, Foster, Spiller, Tate, Gerhart, Ingram, C Michael, L.Murray, Latimore, Pierce, Ballard, Blount, DeAngelo / WR - NONE / TE - Graham, J.Thomas / DST - None / K - NONE ----
    ----10 Team Dynasty QB - Luck, Wilson, Eli, Locker/ RB - ADP, McCoy, Lynch,T.Rich, Vereen, Latavius, Turbin, Polk, Denard / WR - AJG, Dez, Cruz, Patterson, Hopkins, T.Williams Wayne, D.Moore, Wheaton / TE - Gronk, J.Thomas, Clay, Rudolph, M.Bennett / K - Walsh / DST - None -----
  • SmittySmitty June 25
    Posts: 8,639
    My take is this. I dont doubt Gerhart as much as I would just trade laterally into a similar player that maybe others are questioning as well (but I am not). Example, Ive twice now upgrade a mediocre passer into Nick Foles using Gerhart as the addition. You could probably bump a top 6-8 fantasy QB into ARod or Brees even, at least in some cases it would fly.
    - Smitty | Owner/Founder
  • rabidbucfan June 26
    Posts: 4,104
    Imo the extra workload that is making him appealing is also what will be his downfall. It may be 3 games or 8 games of good production but then bam down goes Gerhart. Fourth round is to high for me.
    A small group of thoughtful people could change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. - Margaret Mead
    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • chuckeycharles June 26
    Posts: 2,417
    rabidbucfan said:

    Imo the extra workload that is making him appealing is also what will be his downfall. It may be 3 games or 8 games of good production but then bam down goes Gerhart. Fourth round is to high for

    Why do you think he can't play 16 games? Maybe my memory is bad, but, J don't remember any injuries. He just had the misfortune of plYing behind AP

    He certainly was a workhorse in college

    ---- Both Leagues - Start QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - K - DST - All TD = 6 / Pass Yd = .04 / Rush-Rec Yd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonuses ----
    ---- 10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3) QB - NONE / RB - L.Bell, D.Martin, Foster, Spiller, Tate, Gerhart, Ingram, C Michael, L.Murray, Latimore, Pierce, Ballard, Blount, DeAngelo / WR - NONE / TE - Graham, J.Thomas / DST - None / K - NONE ----
    ----10 Team Dynasty QB - Luck, Wilson, Eli, Locker/ RB - ADP, McCoy, Lynch,T.Rich, Vereen, Latavius, Turbin, Polk, Denard / WR - AJG, Dez, Cruz, Patterson, Hopkins, T.Williams Wayne, D.Moore, Wheaton / TE - Gronk, J.Thomas, Clay, Rudolph, M.Bennett / K - Walsh / DST - None -----
  • chuckeycharles June 26
    Posts: 2,417
    Stupid cell phone
    ---- Both Leagues - Start QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - K - DST - All TD = 6 / Pass Yd = .04 / Rush-Rec Yd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonuses ----
    ---- 10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3) QB - NONE / RB - L.Bell, D.Martin, Foster, Spiller, Tate, Gerhart, Ingram, C Michael, L.Murray, Latimore, Pierce, Ballard, Blount, DeAngelo / WR - NONE / TE - Graham, J.Thomas / DST - None / K - NONE ----
    ----10 Team Dynasty QB - Luck, Wilson, Eli, Locker/ RB - ADP, McCoy, Lynch,T.Rich, Vereen, Latavius, Turbin, Polk, Denard / WR - AJG, Dez, Cruz, Patterson, Hopkins, T.Williams Wayne, D.Moore, Wheaton / TE - Gronk, J.Thomas, Clay, Rudolph, M.Bennett / K - Walsh / DST - None -----
  • rabidbucfan June 26
    Posts: 4,104
    He's had the MCL repair end of 2012, hammy issues off and on through out his career that have all cost him some playing time while in a back up capacity. I love to watch the guy run - he's the bull in the china shop- I just don't think he'll hold up to the rigors of an every down back for the entire season. RB2 sure - in the 5th or 6th round would be more to my liking not the 4th.
     
    A small group of thoughtful people could change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. - Margaret Mead
    DC Nation Forum Moderator
12›
Add a Comment