Calvin trade

This leagues roster reqs are 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 RB/WR/TE, 2 QB/RB/WR/TE,1 K, 2 DB, 2 DL, 2 LB, 2 DB/DL/LB

So basically I can start up to 3 QBs. 6pts on all TDs.

In this format, Would anyone trade Calvin and Sanchez for either Eli or Romo and Bowe??My starters would be:

Romo (or Eli), Cutler, Freeman
Foster, Dmac, Wells
Bowe, Jennings
V. Davis

That's a messed up question to ask a fantasy owner!

Wow, I almost can even consider the impact a QB has in a third starting spot over a Calvin.

I say no. I realize QBs score a lot, and are sought after like crazy in your league, but I'd shoot higher. I'd creatively look to acquire undervalued Mike Vick (first without giving up Calvin), who could really turn out to be a steal this year, especially in this format and this scoring... Then, if that fails, try getting a Vick and WR like Bowe for Calvin... Then if thats a no go, attack the already forgotten Sam Bradford using players not named Calvin.. Bradfors still has top 5-10 fantasy potential despite also having bust potential.

In other words, there are other moves to be made, my friend!

I hear what you're saying Smitty, but i see him with some solid RBs and TEs. Also, Romo/Eli becomes his top QB.

Not saying i would, but not saying i wouldn't. This seems even to me with Bowe thrown in. Can you imagine this startup? I would expect about 15 of the first 20 picks to be QBs lol

No keep Calvin. Not good enough for you.

I think this option was discussed in another thread and I still think you can do much better than Romo or Eli in return for Calvin. Have you inquired with the owners of Rodgers, Cam, Stafford, Brees, etc............?

^ i agree. dont sell calvin short...

Whos_Ur_Doggie said:

I think this option was discussed in another thread and I still think you can do much better than Romo or Eli in return for Calvin. Have you inquired with the owners of Rodgers, Cam, Stafford, Brees, etc............?

I have not talked to those owners. I put Calvin on the block to see what I would get and so far this is it. His first offer was Eli and A. Brown which I declined. The s is his counter. I am torn on this one.

The owners of Cam, Arod, Stafford and Brees are short at QB leaving them with Sanchez as their #1. This trade would give me the best starting QB lineup in the league.

I could reject and try Smitty's suggestion and hope he comes back with more.

Newton owner has Harvin.....could do Cam/Harvin?

Rodgers owner has Austin and Stevie....could do Rodgers and Austin/Stevie??

I might for Cam and Harvin. Rodgers and Austin would be the better deal.

I sent two offers......

#1 Sanchez, Wells, R. Williams and R. Wayne and Calvin for Cam, CJ2K and Harvin

#2 Sanchez and Calvin for Rodgers and Austin (doubt this gets accepted).

I guess we will see. Thanks fellas!

I prob would value Cam and Aaron more than Calvin in this format, so if you got more back that would be solid.

Smitty said:

I prob would value Cam and Aaron more than Calvin in this format, so if you got more back that would be solid.

You think Im asking for too much Smitty? I kinda feel tgat way with the Rodgers deal, but I feel like the Cam deal is close to fair. The Cam owner also has Roethy and Dalton so this move would be better for him then the Rodgers owner.

TBL said:

Smitty said:

I prob would value Cam and Aaron more than Calvin in this format, so if you got more back that would be solid.

You think Im asking for too much Smitty? I kinda feel tgat way with the Rodgers deal, but I feel like the Cam deal is close to fair. The Cam owner also has Roethy and Dalton so this move would be better for him then the Rodgers owner.

Which Williams?

Cam in that league is insane... And you get Cj2k? That's a lot to ask for but try. I'd trade all that for Cam alone ;) but that's me. I feel like I'm missing something, that's how off it feels ;)

TBL said:

I sent two offers......

#1 Sanchez, Wells, R. Williams and R. Wayne and Calvin for Cam, CJ2K and Harvin

#2 Sanchez and Calvin for Rodgers and Austin (doubt this gets accepted).

I guess we will see. Thanks fellas!

Is this deal still in play? I am very curious to see what happens.

Cam deal got shot down. I countered my offer with Sanchez and Calvin for Cam and Harvin. no reply yet.

Now I am second guessing weather I should have taken the Eli and Bowe for Sanchez and Calvin deal.......

No you made the right move

Reisssox said:

No you made the right move

Agreed.

TBL said:

Now I am second guessing weather I should have taken the Eli and Bowe for Sanchez and Calvin deal.......

I wouldn't do a deal just because you are receiving no better offers.. Calvin is the best dynasty WR in the game and neither player you are getting in the Eli/Bowe deal is near the top at their position. If you like it go with your gut, but Cam straight up for Calvin in a 2QB league is a fine swap IMO. Getting harvin is gravy.

Smitty said:

Reisssox said:

No you made the right move

Agreed.

TBL said:

Now I am second guessing weather I should have taken the Eli and Bowe for Sanchez and Calvin deal.......

I wouldn't do a deal just because you are receiving no better offers.. Calvin is the best dynasty WR in the game and neither player you are getting in the Eli/Bowe deal is near the top at their position. If you like it go with your gut, but Cam straight up for Calvin in a 2QB league is a fine swap IMO. Getting harvin is gravy.

Thanks for the input fellas. The Cam/Harvin deal just got shot down as well. My only offer left on the board is Sanchez, Calvin, wells and R.Willims for Roethy, CJ2k and Harvin.

i would be looking to move dirty sanchez at all cost...but not give away calvin with him...keep calvin on the block you will get offers for a stud like him..patience on the #1 wr in the game..

Howdy, Stranger!

Categories

In this Discussion

Top Posters

Who's Online (3)