• Smitty October 2012

  Posts: 5,848

  Many are down on him, but he remains inside my top 3-5 for 2012 QBs... curious what everyone else thinks.
  

  - Smitty | Owner/Founder | DraftCalc.com
• Troy_Polamalyourass October 2012

  Posts: 2,163

  No particular order
  Rodgers
  Brady
  Brees
  Ryan
  P Manning
  E Manning
  
  Then I have Cam/Luck/RG3 together in this area

  Non PPR Dynasty
  1 pt every 50 yds passing/20 yds rushing
  4 pt passing TD
  
  QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE
  
  P Manning, Luck
  Richardson, Spiller, L Bell, Ridley, Z Stacy,
  J Franklin, Michael, Tate, B Pierce, B Brown
  Calvin, AJ Green, Marshall, Britt, Shorts, Floyd (AZ)
  Gronk, Myers
  3 2014 1sts
• Smitty October 2012

  Posts: 5,848

  Troy_Polamalyourass said:

  No particular order
  Rodgers
  Brady
  Brees
  Ryan
  P Manning
  E Manning
  
  Then I have Cam/Luck/RG3 together in this area

  
  
  That's a great list, and very arguable. How many years do you think Peyton will play at a high level? And, how many years do you think he will play period?
  

  - Smitty | Owner/Founder | DraftCalc.com
• JRMRRT October 2012

  Posts: 10,774

  You listed for 2012 Smitty. Are we talking this year or long term?

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• garyzab October 2012

  Posts: 6,414

  I think Smitty means for this year.
  

  DC6
  
  Qb RG3, Locker
  Wr DT, Shorts, Givens, Austin, Harper, Stills, Vince Brown, TJ Graham
  Rb Forte, Reggie Bush, Vereen, Turbin, Pead, LMJ
  Te Davis, Cameron, Myers
  K Blair Walsh
  Def Packers, Patriots
• Whos_Ur_Doggie October 2012

  Posts: 11,693

  Rodgers
  Brees
  Brady
  Ryan
  Peyton
  Cam
  

  DC Nation Moderator
• garyzab October 2012

  Posts: 6,414

  Brees
  Rodgers
  Brady
  Ryan
  RG3
  Peyton
  Eli
  Cam
  

  DC6
  
  Qb RG3, Locker
  Wr DT, Shorts, Givens, Austin, Harper, Stills, Vince Brown, TJ Graham
  Rb Forte, Reggie Bush, Vereen, Turbin, Pead, LMJ
  Te Davis, Cameron, Myers
  K Blair Walsh
  Def Packers, Patriots
• Troy_Polamalyourass October 2012

  Posts: 2,163

  Smitty said:

  
  

  Troy_Polamalyourass said:

  No particular order Rodgers Brady Brees Ryan P Manning E Manning Then I have Cam/Luck/RG3 together in this area

  That's a great list, and very arguable. How many years do you think Peyton will play at a high level? And, how many years do you think he will play period?
  

  
  

  
  I thought this was for this year only...but, to answer your question, I see Peyton playing for at least 3 more years barring injury.

  
  

  I believe his length of stay will be based on participating/winning an AFC/SuperBowl game...

  
  

  I don't see Peyton ever being out of top eight QB #s barring injury

  Non PPR Dynasty
  1 pt every 50 yds passing/20 yds rushing
  4 pt passing TD
  
  QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE
  
  P Manning, Luck
  Richardson, Spiller, L Bell, Ridley, Z Stacy,
  J Franklin, Michael, Tate, B Pierce, B Brown
  Calvin, AJ Green, Marshall, Britt, Shorts, Floyd (AZ)
  Gronk, Myers
  3 2014 1sts
• Smitty October 2012

  Posts: 5,848

  I am talking this year for this discussion, but wanted to ask that long term question. Just curious what people think of Manning. Didn't mean to get off topic ;)

  - Smitty | Owner/Founder | DraftCalc.com
• fontaines October 2012

  Posts: 3,713

  Smitty said:

  I am talking this year for this discussion, but wanted to ask that long term question. Just curious what people think of Manning. Didn't mean to get off topic ;)

  
  
  I give Manning a 2 year window including this year.  But to be honest, i really only give qbs a 3 year window in dynasty anyway.  i usually have traded them by then lol.  The only QB i've ever held onto for more than 3 years is Brees.

  
  

  Though i like how he plays, i would still take Cam over Manning in redraft.  i think Cam is having major mental issues right now and thats it.  he just needs a kick in the ass.  i'm hoping it comes this year (i feel it will), but i'm not worried about him long term.  

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• Mile_High_Man October 2012

  Posts: 3,465

  In no order

  Rogers

  Brady

  Brees

  Peyton

  Eli

  RGIII

  Ryan

  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope. Then you will call upon Me and go and pray to Me, and I will listen to you. And you will seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart. Jeremiah 29:11-13 New King James Version (NKJV)
  
  Draft Calc - Moderator
  

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft