• andr3wl January 15

  Posts: 1,081

  Who do you want for dynasty and why?
• Whos_Ur_Doggie January 15

  Posts: 11,693

  Cam.... rushing & passing TD's.  Yes, Luck can rush for TD's but not as frequent as Cam does.
  

  DC Nation Moderator
• bddavidson January 15

  Posts: 10,417

  flip a coin or take the one u like best they will be top 5 for years to come..

  DC Nation Moderator
• N_Diddy January 15

  Posts: 1,496

  Close for me ... but I'll take Cam, rushing TDs do it for me too....
• Jamesal January 15

  Posts: 141

  I'll take luck
• BuckysGT January 15

  Posts: 7,385

  I like Cam. He bring more opportunities for tds.
  
• bddavidson January 15

  Posts: 10,417

  BuckysGT said:

  I like Cam. He bring more opportunities for tds.
  

  
  
  Cam-27 tds this past year

  Luck-28 tds this past year

  
  

  Edit

  
  

  just sayin TDs are close.. now rushing tds are greater for Cam and his rushing yards are much greater as JR points out .

  DC Nation Moderator
• JRMRRT January 15

  Posts: 10,774

  I like Cam...Rushing yards were 740 to 250. Thats 50 more points right there.I know Luck had more passing yards but they are not score 1/10 like rushing. I guess format would have a lot to do here as well.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• bddavidson January 15

  Posts: 10,417

  JRMRRT said:

  I like Cam...Rushing yards were 740 to 250. Thats 50 more points right there.I know Luck had more passing yards but they are not score 1/10 like rushing. I guess format would have a lot to do here as well.

  
  
  agreed. I like cam as well for this simple fact..those rushing yards do add up.

  DC Nation Moderator
• TheHuddle January 15

  Posts: 1,116

  If Cam becomes a great nfl qb it won't be because of his rushing stats. I'd rather have Luck.
  
  
• JRMRRT January 15

  Posts: 10,774

  TheHuddle said:

  If Cam becomes a great nfl qb it won't be because of his rushing stats. I'd rather have Luck.
  
  

  
  
  I dont care if he becomes a great NFL QB. I care if he puts up fantasy points cause this is FF we are talking about. If he throws for around 4000 yards and runs for 700-900 yards and and produces TDs Im am a happy owner.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• LukeB5301 January 15

  Posts: 6,998

  I'll take Cam here

  My 2013 Predictions[Non-PPR]:
  [:(] C.J. Spiller Will Be The #1RB(Jan 9th)
  [ ] Demaryius Thomas will be the #1 scoring WR!(Feb 13th)
  [ ] Trent Richardson will NOT finish as a Top 10 RB!(June 4th)
  [:(] Rob Housler will be a Top 5 TE in 2013!(July 18th)
  [ ] Josh Gordon will put up a 80/1200/10 stat line in just 14 Games!(Sept 5th)
• BuckysGT January 15

  Posts: 7,385

  TheHuddle said:

  If Cam becomes a great nfl qb it won't be because of his rushing stats. I'd rather have Luck.
  
  

  
  
  Just like JR said, I could care less if he is a great NFL qb. I want fantasy stats. Cam produces very good fantasy stats.
  
• branch0095 January 15

  Posts: 3,519

  Id take Cam here as well, but how close it is would depend on QB scoring. 1pt/20yds and 6pt passing TDs is alot closer then 1pt/25 or 4pt passing TDs to me.

  2013 predictions
  
  -Cobb outscores Harvin in PPR
  -Chris Ivory will be a top 15RB
  -Kenny Britt finishes outside the top 20WRs
• haimez40 January 17

  Posts: 2,375

  I'm taking Luck. Cam has higher ceiling, but I consider him selfish headcase. Cam could be best player in all of fantasy no doubt, but he worries too much about his street cred and view of the public. It will come back to haunt him.
  
  As for Luck he proved he can excell, he took his lumps and got back up. Colts are a better organization also and I trust them more to give Luck what he needs.

  I don't trust Adam Schefter and neither should you!!!
• Wutthecrapman January 17

  Posts: 8,764

  For fantasy the nod goes to Cam Newton. For every other aspect of the game, Andrew Luck.
  
  Two totally different players, and persons with polar opposite mentalities. I adore Luck as a human and how he carries himself and his mates.
  
  However Andrew asked about fantasy strictly, and the answer points clearly to Cam.
  

  
  "I'm like birth control. You have to believe in me. Like birth control, 99.9 percent of the time I'm going to come through for you." - David Wilson
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• TheHuddle January 17

  Posts: 1,116

  I think Luck will put up better #'s over his career. If Willie Beamen continues to put up 4000 & 7-900 rushing for 12 years he would be considered great, but I'm taking Luck's side over the long-term.  Fantasy or real football.  Luck produced 4,374/23td's & ran 255/5td's in his rookie year. 

  
  

  
  

  
  

  
  

  
  

  
  
• fontaines January 17

  Posts: 3,713

  Cam, during a sophomore slump he still finished QB3.  Can't ignore rushing yards and rushing tds in any format.  Certainly wouldn't oppose someone taking luck though, especially in a startup

  DC Nation Forum Moderator

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft