• k0wned June 16

  Posts: 206

  10 team non-PPR redraft, we start 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE

  
  

  My team:

  
  

  QB: R. Wilson

  WR: Marshall, DT, Harvin, Gordon, Hilton, Jennings

  RB: Spiller, Wilson, Vereen, Pead, Stacy

  TE: Gronk, Finley

  
  

  I was offered Miller, R Bush, and M Ball for Spiller. 

  
  

  His team:

  QB: Cam, Luck

  WR: Julio, Britt, T Austin, James Jones, Michael Floyd

  RB: R Bush, CJ2k, McFadden, Miller, Ball

  TE: Cook, Cameron

  
  

  That is not a bad offer, but I don't like trading studs for depth in 10 team leagues. This was his initial offer though, so any counters make sense? 
• branch0095 June 16

  Posts: 3,519

  Like you said, 10 teamers are stud driven leagues. That's a nice haul, but Id just keep Spiller. Since it's non PPR, turning this into a multi-player deal and getting Julio in return is the only thing that may peak my interest.

  2013 predictions
  
  -Cobb outscores Harvin in PPR
  -Chris Ivory will be a top 15RB
  -Kenny Britt finishes outside the top 20WRs
• rickok21 June 16

  Posts: 3,265

  Yeah hang with what you have.  I have a rule with studs...I better be getting a sure thing in return.  
• JRMRRT June 16

  Posts: 10,774

  Wow....great offer but it makes your starters weaker so Id keep Spiller. Tough to pass that up though. 

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• emurrell17 June 16

  Posts: 1,626

  I'd offer something like this that helps your starters a little bit in return...

  You give

  Spiller, R. Wilson, and Harvin

  
  

  for

  Julio, Cam, Miller

  
  

  Idk how others feel about that, but in something like that you are getting upgrades at 2/3 positions in turn for your stud...so i think that's pretty fair.

  Bold Predictions:
  June 21- Dez Bryant finishes as the #1 WR in 2013.
  
• k0wned June 16

  Posts: 206

  
  

  emurrell17 said:

  I'd offer something like this that helps your starters a little bit in return...

  You give

  Spiller, R. Wilson, and Harvin

  
  

  for

  Julio, Cam, Miller

  
  

  Idk how others feel about that, but in something like that you are getting upgrades at 2/3 positions in turn for your stud...so i think that's pretty fair.

  
  
  Seems fair, but I still prefer the Spiller/Wilson/Harvin side slightly so not worth it. I agree that the only way for it to make sense for me is to include Julio
• emurrell17 June 17

  Posts: 1,626

  k0wned said:

  
  

  emurrell17 said:

  I'd offer something like this that helps your starters a little bit in return...

  You give

  Spiller, R. Wilson, and Harvin

  
  

  for

  Julio, Cam, Miller

  
  

  Idk how others feel about that, but in something like that you are getting upgrades at 2/3 positions in turn for your stud...so i think that's pretty fair.

  
  
  Seems fair, but I still prefer the Spiller/Wilson/Harvin side slightly so not worth it. I agree that the only way for it to make sense for me is to include Julio

  
  Right..you don't have to use that trade I just thought it was a good starting point.
  

  Bold Predictions:
  June 21- Dez Bryant finishes as the #1 WR in 2013.
  
• Whos_Ur_Doggie June 17

  Posts: 11,693

  I'd keep Spiller over all that.  Moving Spiller for depth weakens your team in a 10 team league.

  DC Nation Moderator

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft