• jintsfan66 July 5

  Posts: 463

  I have been approached by a team for RG3. The offer is a 2014 RD1 guaranteed, 2015 RD 1 conditional, 2016 RD 1 conditional. The conditions are that RG3 must finish in the top 10 for QB in those years, if not the 2015 and 2016 RD 1 become 2nd Round picks. In our leagues 4 year existence this team has had a top 4 pick every year.

   

  At first glance, I am not crazy about the offer and it is difficult to put value on those picks. It can be a good way for my team to fill the pipeline as my team has been a contender every year and usually have the 9th or 10th pick annually. I am just not crazy with this idea. Am I wrong? just looking for some help from the DC faithful

   

  Here is his roster for guidance to what his picks may be. He has a decent young team with some holes. I have been trying forever to get Spiller but to no avail. Is there anything he can add to make me feel better? more fair?

   

   

  Really need some help here guys, thanks and look forward to the response

   

  QB Vick, Roethlisberger

  RB Wilson, Spiller, Mathews, Pierce, Ballard

  WR V Brown, Lloyd, Hill, Hilton, Randle, L. Moore, Streeter, Roberts

  TE Finley

   

  Team #1
  QB - Arod, Rivers
  RB - AP, T rich, Spiller, Pierce,Vereen, Moreno, BJGE
  WR - Julio Jones, Cobb, Nicks, T. Smith, TY Hilton, M. Brown
  TE - Graham, Thomas
  D- SF
  K- Akers
  Taxi: C. Patterson Michael
  
  Starting Requirements: 1 QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1Flex RB/WR/TE, 1K, 1 DEF 1 PPR
  
  
• LukeB5301 July 5

  Posts: 6,998

  Rg3 for possibly 3 1st?? Not close IMO

  My 2013 Predictions[Non-PPR]:
  [:(] C.J. Spiller Will Be The #1RB(Jan 9th)
  [ ] Demaryius Thomas will be the #1 scoring WR!(Feb 13th)
  [ ] Trent Richardson will NOT finish as a Top 10 RB!(June 4th)
  [:(] Rob Housler will be a Top 5 TE in 2013!(July 18th)
  [ ] Josh Gordon will put up a 80/1200/10 stat line in just 14 Games!(Sept 5th)
• N_Diddy July 5

  Posts: 1,496

  Assuming that's the second team in your sig ... you could deal RG3 - but no way I do it without getting a proven player in return.  Your team is flipping stacked!  If your starting req's are ARod, AP/TR, Julio/Cobb, Graham at flex ... you're good to go ... I'd hold out for a better offer - maybe try grabbing Calvin, AJG or Martin with him.  
• emurrell17 July 5

  Posts: 1,626

  Ya. Don't sell him when people are iffy about him. Wait until he comes back and starts whooping ass again..a couple of weeks into the season and he will be worth much more

  Bold Predictions:
  June 21- Dez Bryant finishes as the #1 WR in 2013.
  
• Smitty July 5

  Posts: 5,848

  I'm the guy buying RG3 at a discount.

  - Smitty | Owner/Founder | DraftCalc.com
• jintsfan66 July 5

  Posts: 463

  that is what I thought!! that is why I threw out to you guys!! I offered this guy RG3, CJ2K and Torrey Smith and a 2014 2nd for Spiller and the 1.4 but he rejected it.

   

  My main target has been Smitty's boy CJ Spiller, Guy will not let go...lol

  Team #1
  QB - Arod, Rivers
  RB - AP, T rich, Spiller, Pierce,Vereen, Moreno, BJGE
  WR - Julio Jones, Cobb, Nicks, T. Smith, TY Hilton, M. Brown
  TE - Graham, Thomas
  D- SF
  K- Akers
  Taxi: C. Patterson Michael
  
  Starting Requirements: 1 QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1Flex RB/WR/TE, 1K, 1 DEF 1 PPR
  
  
• stewss7 July 5

  Posts: 433

  Smitty said:

  I'm the guy buying RG3 at a discount.

  
  
  I'm the guy selling on rg3. He's a much better passing Michael Vick minus the criminal aspect. He'll never play a full 16 game schedule. I'd do the deal if I could get two of the three picks guaranteed.

  @stewss7
• bddavidson July 5

  Posts: 10,417

  I offered DMAc for RG3 is that close?

  DC Nation Moderator
• meast July 5

  Posts: 1,204

  bddavidson said:

  I offered DMAc for RG3 is that close?

  
  
  Not close at all imo
• bddavidson July 5

  Posts: 10,417

  dmac ranked with the injured RG3

   

  here 21 st for rg3 and dmac 24 so I think not bad an offer?

  DC Nation Moderator
• meast July 5

  Posts: 1,204

  RB ranked 16-20 range is worth less than top 5 QB.....of course league size and scoring will determine to what degree
• meast July 5

  Posts: 1,204

  Worth a shot....you never know
• Reisssox July 5

  Posts: 2,869

  Qbs can be a hard trade in 1 start...I sat on Brady for a long time before I was able to move him
• Reisssox July 5

  Posts: 2,869

  Value outside of DC on RG3 is not as high...D Mac is a very fair offer
• bddavidson July 5

  Posts: 10,417

  it is a start 1 thought was a fair offer maybe i am wrong?

  DC Nation Moderator
• branch0095 July 5

  Posts: 3,519

  bddavidson said:

  it is a start 1 thought was a fair offer maybe i am wrong?

  
  
  
  I think it's fair but I'm notoriously low on QBs as a whole in a start 1QB league. The problem you may have is just the stigma attached to DMC. The ADP value is right though IMO, and if you offered a handful of other players in DMCs range you would probably have success with the offer. The number or people holding out hope for DMC is getting smaller by the day. 2012 was the final straw for a lot of owners when it comes to DMC. I guess it would only be fitting that 2013 would be the season DMC played 16 games and ended as a RB1.

  2013 predictions
  
  -Cobb outscores Harvin in PPR
  -Chris Ivory will be a top 15RB
  -Kenny Britt finishes outside the top 20WRs
• BuckysGT July 6

  Posts: 7,385

  2015 and 2016 1sts have almost no value right now. This isn't even close.
• jintsfan66 July 6

  Posts: 463

  Thanks guys, I figured it was crazy and you all have confirmed it. I will sit on him until his value spikes even more.

  Team #1
  QB - Arod, Rivers
  RB - AP, T rich, Spiller, Pierce,Vereen, Moreno, BJGE
  WR - Julio Jones, Cobb, Nicks, T. Smith, TY Hilton, M. Brown
  TE - Graham, Thomas
  D- SF
  K- Akers
  Taxi: C. Patterson Michael
  
  Starting Requirements: 1 QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1Flex RB/WR/TE, 1K, 1 DEF 1 PPR
  
  
• MikeOcherts August 5

  Posts: 740

  Bump for removal of spam...
• CB_75 August 6

  Posts: 705

  Reisssox said:

  Value outside of DC on RG3 is not as high...D Mac is a very fair offer

  
  
  Value outside of DC not that high because they only remember the end of the season, not everything he did leading up to the injury!
  
  This kid is a freak and will quickly remind 'Everyone' why he is a STUD! The nature of his play will leave ppl skeptical forever, he's simply not built like Cam...but he'll score around the same! He'll get smarter with his runs, he'll protect himself better at the end of them...
  
  Now, say it after me; STUD!

  "Good, better, best. Never let it rest, until your good is better and your better is best!" - Tim Duncan

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft