• TTB9 July 8

  Posts: 178

  Got offer straight up swapping RBs in a $ redraft league.
  
  I give Wilson for rookie Bell. At this point, either RB would be a bench guy.
  
  10 team non-ppr league with lineup of: QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, K, DEF
  
  My roster:
  
  QB- RG3
  WR- Fitzgerald, Cobb, Welker, Amendola, Gordon, Britt, DMoore
  RB- Spiller, Richardson, Wilson, Mendenhall
  TE- Pitta
  
  Thanks
  
• Wutthecrapman July 8

  Posts: 8,764

  Non ppr I can slightly get why you would. To me its more of a wash. I have Wilson over Bell by a hair.
  
  Any reason why you'd consider doing this? Wilson seems to be on the edge of breaking out...
  

  
  "I'm like birth control. You have to believe in me. Like birth control, 99.9 percent of the time I'm going to come through for you." - David Wilson
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• popo24 July 8

  Posts: 768

  No.

  
  
• fontaines July 8

  Posts: 3,713

  I wouldn't bat an eye if I saw this trade go down, but most likely would keep Wilson by a small margin.  

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• Whos_Ur_Doggie July 8

  Posts: 11,693

  I have Bell one spot ahead of Wilson in my rankings so this really is a lateral move IMO.  Go with who you like the most since neither are starting over Spiller or TRich.   ;)

  DC Nation Moderator
• pemo July 8

  Posts: 870

  I wouldn't.  I think Wilson has the higher ceiling, and that's your play at this point.

  Predictions
  
  [ ] Percy Harvin will be a top 5 PPR wide receiver, outscoring Cobb
  [ ] Danny Amendola will be a top 15 PPR wide receiver
  [ ] Russel Wilson will be a top 4 QB
  [ ] Denario Alexander will be a top 15 PPR WR
• haimez40 July 8

  Posts: 2,375

  No way in any league I would do this.  Wilson arguably has a top 5 OLine where Bell will behind one of the worst. 
  

  I don't trust Adam Schefter and neither should you!!!
• TTB9 July 8

  Posts: 178

  Thanks fellas. I wasn't sure how to really compare them. I've heard Bell should be a 3 down RB for Pitt but was that enough to make the swap? Wilson will share with ABrown but I agree his ceiling should be higher... Just need to keep the ball in his hands!
  
  I snagged Wilson in the 7th round (68th overall) so was very happy with that.
• haimez40 July 8

  Posts: 2,375

  TTB9 said:

  Thanks fellas. I wasn't sure how to really compare them. I've heard Bell should be a 3 down RB for Pitt but was that enough to make the swap? Wilson will share with ABrown but I agree his ceiling should be higher... Just need to keep the ball in his hands!
  
  I snagged Wilson in the 7th round (68th overall) so was very happy with that.

  
  
  I would take Wilson at 15 carries for NYG over Bell at 30 for Pitt.  Don't get me wrong though Bell has upside.  Their Oline is just banged up.  Wilson has break away HR speed though you can't get anywhere.
  

  I don't trust Adam Schefter and neither should you!!!
• TTB9 July 8

  Posts: 178

  haimez40 said:

  TTB9 said:

  Thanks fellas. I wasn't sure how to really compare them. I've heard Bell should be a 3 down RB for Pitt but was that enough to make the swap? Wilson will share with ABrown but I agree his ceiling should be higher... Just need to keep the ball in his hands!
  
  I snagged Wilson in the 7th round (68th overall) so was very happy with that.

  
  
  I would take Wilson at 15 carries for NYG over Bell at 30 for Pitt.  Don't get me wrong though Bell has upside.  Their Oline is just banged up.  Wilson has break away HR speed though you can't get anywhere.
  

  
  
  Thanks! Like to hear that since I recently got JCharles/Wilson for Morris/AJohnson in my dynasty league.
  
  
• haimez40 July 8

  Posts: 2,375

  TTB9 said:

  
  
  Thanks! Like to hear that since I recently got JCharles/Wilson for Morris/AJohnson in my dynasty league.
  
  

  
  
  I would do that trade any day of the week!!!!  Nice work.
  

  I don't trust Adam Schefter and neither should you!!!
• Reisssox July 8

  Posts: 2,869

  Charles trade was just sick...great deal!
• JRMRRT July 8

  Posts: 10,774

  Wilson over Bell for me. He can do more with less.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• branch0095 July 8

  Posts: 3,519

  JRMRRT said:

  Wilson over Bell for me. He can do more with less.

  
  
  
  This. In your situation it's all about upside here, not reliable production. Even in non-ppr I don't see Ball having the upside that Wilson does for 2013.

  2013 predictions
  
  -Cobb outscores Harvin in PPR
  -Chris Ivory will be a top 15RB
  -Kenny Britt finishes outside the top 20WRs
• bddavidson July 10

  Posts: 10,417

  haimez40 said:

  No way in any league I would do this.  Wilson arguably has a top 5 OLine where Bell will behind one of the worst. 
  

  
  
  Now if you said Gio no problem lol...just messing with ya buddy!

  DC Nation Moderator
• haimez40 July 10

  Posts: 2,375

  bddavidson said:

  
  
  Now if you said Gio no problem lol...just messing with ya buddy!

  
  
  I would take Wilson over Gio too.  I do like both though. ;)
  

  I don't trust Adam Schefter and neither should you!!!
• bddavidson July 10

  Posts: 10,417

  haimez40 said:

  bddavidson said:

  
  
  Now if you said Gio no problem lol...just messing with ya buddy!

  
  
  I would take Wilson over Gio too.  I do like both though. ;)
  

  
  
  hahahaha love you man!

  DC Nation Moderator

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft