• TTB9 August 6

  Posts: 178

  Got an offer in my 10 team $ league.
  
  No flex or PPR. Start QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, K, DEF
  
  Currently have no kicker or defense... so before season starts I will need to drop 2 guys or make a trade to free up some spots. FA market is deep though.
  
  So I would give VJax & Gore for Garcon & LMiller.
  
  My roster:
  Stafford
  Calvin, VJax, Amendola, TAustin, Hilton, Hopkins, Dobson
  SJax, Gore, DWilson, Bernard, Pierce
  Gates, Cameron
  
  His roster:
  PManning
  Marshall, Garcon, GJennings, Jeffrey, SRice
  Morris, LMiller, Ivory, Bradshaw, Ballard
  Olsen, FDavis
  
  Do you like this trade for me?
  
  Thanks!
• Smitty August 6

  Posts: 5,848

  That's a tough one, as VJax is solid.. but I do it. YOu have some sleeper WR talent toss in VJax's spot, and Gore is on his way down, that's selling pretty high when it comes to Gore, IMO. 

  
  

  Other thoughts? I take it. I also sell SJax if possible, as you can start Wilson and Miller, maybe you get a Julio Jones for SJax and someone, maybe even picks? Not suggesting you don't roll into the season without a stronger RB3, but you can make another trade. Sit on Pierce, he could really be a nice late in the season stud.

  Nice team.

  - Smitty | Owner/Founder | DraftCalc.com
• TTB August 6

  Posts: 8

  Do you all think a run could be made for Marshall (instead of Garcon) without giving up Calvin?
  
  Something like... VJackson/Gore/TAustin... for Marshall/Miller?  The other team doesn't have the deepest WR core (plus has 2 Chicago WRs).
  
  If a couple guys will eventually need to traded or dropped to clear room for kicker and def... then would this be the time to go all in for Marshall/Miller?
  
  
  
• TTB9 August 6

  Posts: 178

  Thanks Smitty.
  
  Any other thoughts out there?  I still have his offer sitting in my queue to accept (give VJax & Gore for Garcon & LMiller). 
  
  Should I take it... or try to make a move for Marshall & LMiller without giving up Calvin?  If so, how do you think I could get that done?
  
  
• hoyasaxa August 6

  Posts: 218

  While it's always possible that you can do better, I like this deal for you.  I'm high on Miller, and Gore has little appeal to me and little trade value in a dynasty league at this point.  I also think I prefer Garcon to VJax, but I could be in a minority here.  Something about Jackson never appealed to me.

  
  

  If you could to VJax/Gore/Austion for Marshall and Miller, I'd say do that, but I don't know if you'll get that.  No harm in offering, as long as you don;t think you'll lose the current offer and regret it.
• TTB9 August 6

  Posts: 178

  hoyasaxa said:

  While it's always possible that you can do better, I like this deal for you.  I'm high on Miller, and Gore has little appeal to me and little trade value in a dynasty league at this point.  I also think I prefer Garcon to VJax, but I could be in a minority here.  Something about Jackson never appealed to me.

  
  

  If you could to VJax/Gore/Austion for Marshall and Miller, I'd say do that, but I don't know if you'll get that.  No harm in offering, as long as you don;t think you'll lose the current offer and regret it.

  
  
  Thanks.  This is for redraft... does that change anything?
  
• bwags August 6

  Posts: 698

  TTB9 said:

  hoyasaxa said:

  While it's always possible that you can do better, I like this deal for you.  I'm high on Miller, and Gore has little appeal to me and little trade value in a dynasty league at this point.  I also think I prefer Garcon to VJax, but I could be in a minority here.  Something about Jackson never appealed to me.

  
  

  If you could to VJax/Gore/Austion for Marshall and Miller, I'd say do that, but I don't know if you'll get that.  No harm in offering, as long as you don;t think you'll lose the current offer and regret it.

  
  
  Thanks.  This is for redraft... does that change anything?
  

  
  
  Redraft I don't do that deal. Gore is probably still going to be a top 15 RB this year and vjax is much better than garçon, who is hurt all the time. Miller is great and should have a good year but in redraft stick with the safer play.
  

  Non PPR 10 team Dynasty 2qbs 2-4 rbs 3-5 wrs 1 te 1 def 1 k
  Cam Newton, Tony Romo, EJ Manuel, Carson Palmer
  Julio Jones, Larry Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Percy Harvin, Michael Crabtree, DeAndre Hopkins, Keenan Allen
  Trent Richardson, CJ Spiller, Lamar Miller, Darren Sproles, Shane Vereen, Marcus Lattimore, Khiry Robinson, Bryce Brown
  Jared Cook
  Greg Zuerlien
  Carolina
• TTB9 August 6

  Posts: 178

  That was my hesitation to immediately pull it.  While there is a little unknown about Miller in the full time gig... Gore should be good for another year.  Garcon is back... but did miss a ton last season.
  
  Then again... Miller/Garcon could be decent buy low candidates to start the season.  Just back and forth on if its worth VJax/Gore?
  
  

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft