• stewss7 August 7

  Posts: 433

  .5 PPR, 24 man roster
  Spiller
  Fitzgerald
  Wallace
  S Hill
  Or
  Calvin Johnson
  Chris Johnson
  R Wilson
  2014 1st

  @stewss7
• N_Diddy August 7

  Posts: 1,496

  Close - but I'd take the Calvin side.  

  Spiller >> CJnoK (although this could be close come end of season - I think a lot of people are writing him off and he could surprise this year)

  Calvin > Fitz (love Fitz this year, but IMO Calvin is in a tier all by himself)

  RWilson >>> Wallace (Don't trust Wallace at all ... love the future for Mr Wilson)

  2014 > Hill
• JRMRRT August 7

  Posts: 10,774

  Id need to see your roster

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• stewss7 August 7

  Posts: 433

  Luck
  D Murray
  L Murray
  McFadden
  Pierce
  Turbin
  Stacy
  Spiller
  D Thomas
  Fitzgerald
  Wallace
  Garçon
  Hilton
  Givens
  D Harris
  Hill
  Charles Johnson
  Hopkins
  Olsen
  F Davis
  
  
  
  
  

  @stewss7
• JRMRRT August 7

  Posts: 10,774

  Your WRs are fine and you dont need R Wilson. Id keep Spiller. Your RBs would also be pretty risky with CJunk, DMac and Murray if you made this deal. I agree that the value is on the Calvin side slightly but I dont think its a deal for your team. Remember though that Im very high on Fitz this year.

  ________________________________________________________
  
  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• robbyrobdu August 7

  Posts: 670

  This trade just doesn't make sense unless you are immediately swinging something for a RB.

  
  

  RB is your weakest position even with Spiller.

  
  

  Calvin and DT would be nice together, and having 2 of the best young QBs in the game is nice insurance. But maximizing starters is always key and you get worse at RB by a good sight (I coined him CJnoK for a reason, yes I bet I said it before anyone! Damn I get no respect LMAO).

  
  

  I think it would be better to trade some of the WR depth you have, which is in all honesty pretty insane, for a RB upgrade and you'll have a VERY competitive team.

  
  

  Hold on Spiller for sure. He's going to be arguably the top pick for the next 3-4 years minimum.

  16 Team 40 Man IDP/DST BIG PLAY LEAGUE
  In 5th Year
  
  QB Tom Brady, Russell Wilson
  RB Adrian Peterson, Marshawn Lynch
  RB/WR LeSean McCoy, Ahmad Bradshaw
  WR Marques Colston, Larry Fitzgerald, Wes Welker
  WR/TE Michael Crabtree, Mike Wallace
  TE Jimmy Graham, Rob Gronkowski
  DT Derek Wolfe, Henry Melton
  DE Jared Allen, Whitney Mercilus
  LB London Fletcher, Patrick Willis, Von Miller
  CB Devin McCourty,Jason McCourty
  S Morgan Burnett, Kenny Phillips
  DP Wesley Woodyard
  D/ST Giants, Rams
  K Randy Bullock
  Bench Colin Kaepernick, Toby Gerhart, Mike Tolbert, Travaris Cadet, Michael Smith, Andre Roberts, Rob Housler, Michael Floyd, Vince Young, Damaris Johnson, Nate Irving, Nick Roach, Kellen Winslow, Kenbrell Thompkins, Cierre Wood
• stewss7 August 7

  Posts: 433

  Sorry...D Thomas is Daniel Thomas.

  @stewss7
• TBL August 7

  Posts: 4,426

  Gotta keep Spiller here imo.
• fontaines August 7

  Posts: 3,713

  I've never owned spiller, and if I had I might change my mind here
  
  In all my years of playing fantasy, the single most enjoyable player for me to own ever is Calvin Johnson. I know I'm not really giving any tangible reason for one side or the other, I just think I'd go Calvin here as I see value and he gives a big positional advantage. I think cjnok has one more top 15 year and I like pairing russel Wilson with luck this year for matchups then trade bait later. I think by a tiny hair I'd take Calvin side

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• fontaines August 7

  Posts: 3,713

  stewss7 said:

  Sorry...D Thomas is Daniel Thomas.

  
  
  
  
  
  Shoot totally overlooked that. Your wrs are too weak to give up both fitz and Wallace. Keep spiller

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• robbyrobdu August 7

  Posts: 670

  Yea that changes a lot, definitely the Calvin Side now.

  16 Team 40 Man IDP/DST BIG PLAY LEAGUE
  In 5th Year
  
  QB Tom Brady, Russell Wilson
  RB Adrian Peterson, Marshawn Lynch
  RB/WR LeSean McCoy, Ahmad Bradshaw
  WR Marques Colston, Larry Fitzgerald, Wes Welker
  WR/TE Michael Crabtree, Mike Wallace
  TE Jimmy Graham, Rob Gronkowski
  DT Derek Wolfe, Henry Melton
  DE Jared Allen, Whitney Mercilus
  LB London Fletcher, Patrick Willis, Von Miller
  CB Devin McCourty,Jason McCourty
  S Morgan Burnett, Kenny Phillips
  DP Wesley Woodyard
  D/ST Giants, Rams
  K Randy Bullock
  Bench Colin Kaepernick, Toby Gerhart, Mike Tolbert, Travaris Cadet, Michael Smith, Andre Roberts, Rob Housler, Michael Floyd, Vince Young, Damaris Johnson, Nate Irving, Nick Roach, Kellen Winslow, Kenbrell Thompkins, Cierre Wood
• BuckysGT August 7

  Posts: 7,385

  I like the Calvin side as well.
  
• stewss7 August 12

  Posts: 433

  I've made an amendment to the potential deal.
  
  Spiller, Fitz, Olsen, Wallace & S Hill
  For
  CJ.5K, J Graham, Calvin, R Wilson & 2014 1st rounder.
  
  How does this change the trade?

  @stewss7
• zeeshan2 August 12

  Posts: 1,118

  stewss7 said:

  I've made an amendment to the potential deal.
  
  Spiller, Fitz, Olsen, Wallace & S Hill
  For
  CJ.5K, J Graham, Calvin, R Wilson & 2014 1st rounder.
  
  How does this change the trade?

  
  
  I like the Calvin side by a lot
• thedude August 12

  Posts: 2,538

  Calvin in either scenario

  =====================================
  "It's like what Lenin said... you look for the person who will benefit, and, uh, uh..." - The Dude
  
• k_stewart_21 August 12

  Posts: 39

  calvin

   

   

   

  A. Rodgers
  L. McCoy, M. Lynch, L. Bell, R. Hillman, F. Jackson, B. Brown, M. Bush, D. Robinson
  B. Marshall, R. Wayne, T. Smith, Mi. Floyd, E. Sanders, B. LaFell, S. Holmes
  J. Finely, A. Gates
  
• fontaines August 13

  Posts: 3,713

  stewss7 said:

  I've made an amendment to the potential deal.
  
  Spiller, Fitz, Olsen, Wallace & S Hill
  For
  CJ.5K, J Graham, Calvin, R Wilson & 2014 1st rounder.
  
  How does this change the trade?

  
  
  does that mean he's actually interested?  The ammended Calvin side is winning by a massive margin here.

  DC Nation Forum Moderator
• stewss7 August 13

  Posts: 433

  That's my plan. He's a good friend of mine & has a HUGE man-crush on Spiller. With that said, I think he's just jerkin my chain.

  @stewss7

View DC Nation Leagues: One | Two | Three | Four | Five | Instant Classics III Draft