fantasy football player trade calculator dynastyfantasy football player trade calculator dynastyfantasy football demo trade calculator
MJD or Murray - Forums

DraftCalc Now Has **LIVE** Mock Drafting

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Login with Facebook Sign In with Google Sign In with OpenID Sign In with Twitter
Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion

Tagged

Top Posters

Who's Online (4)

Homepage | Articles | Rankings | Projections | Upside Board | Calcs | Forums | Terms | FAQs - [ Start a New Discussion ]
MJD or Murray
  • gaines99gaines99
    Posts: 3
    In my dynasty lg i have MJD and was offered Murray? Its ppr and bonus its for 100 yards ru or rec. Who is better? Should I do the deal? I like Murray but MJD is the now.
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    Id take Murray but its a tough to thing to do after MJD just won the scoring title.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • rabidbucfanrabidbucfan
    Posts: 2,678
    you know what you have with MJD - Murray is all upside potential
    Endurance is patience concentrated.
    Thomas Carlyle
  • ArtySArtyS
    Posts: 1,325
    I would take the younger Murray also
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    really...now mjd isnt worth murray?...this approach of always getting younger and getting rid of any older players is starting to get a little crazy...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    Its not like Murray is a rookie that hasnt hit the field yet. He led the league in rushing for the 8 games he started.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • RIPPERSRIPPERS
    Posts: 1,178
    I think you can get more for MJD than Just Murray.  Deal MJD because I think his value is as high as it will ever be. Get younger with Murray but get more for him. Don't sell yourself short.
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    JRMRRT said:

    Its not like Murray is a rookie that hasnt hit the field yet. He led the league in rushing for the 8 games he started.




    whoaaa jr...im not saying that murray doesnt outproduce mjd this upcoming season or statistically speaking they arent equal...you misunderstand my take...im saying that TODAY the value of MJD even in a dynasty league where owners think 27 is over the hill MJD has to have more "value" then that...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    RIPPERS said:

    I think you can get more for MJD than Just Murray.  Deal MJD because I think his value is as high as it will ever be. Get younger with Murray but get more for him. Don't sell yourself short.



    I agree but if Im forced to make the decision or am drafting in a startup Im taking Murray.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    JRMRRT said:

    RIPPERS said:

    I think you can get more for MJD than Just Murray.  Deal MJD because I think his value is as high as it will ever be. Get younger with Murray but get more for him. Don't sell yourself short.



    I agree but if Im forced to make the decision or am drafting in a startup Im taking Murray.



    easy to say and post i guess...but with a 500 dollar entry fee are you still willing to take murray with mjd sitting there?
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    JRMRRT said:

    Its not like Murray is a rookie that hasnt hit the field yet. He led the league in rushing for the 8 games he started.




    whoaaa jr...im not saying that murray doesnt outproduce mjd this upcoming season or statistically speaking they arent equal...you misunderstand my take...im saying that TODAY the value of MJD even in a dynasty league where owners think 27 is over the hill MJD has to have more "value" then that...


    But you said..."really...now MJD isnt worth Murray?" Why would you ask that if you think Murray can outproduce MJD or they are statistically equal. I confused.
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    meaning for "fantasy" purposes...there is a difference for me...there are players that i would realistically draft ahead of other players even though i dont think they will be as good statistically speaking...why?...cause i feel like i can move that "value"....
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    i guess bottom line is that i cant predict the future...murray may have a better season then mjd this year...i dont doubt that it could happen...im just saying that as of today mjd should land more then murray in my opinion
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    FarFromHome said:

    JRMRRT said:

    RIPPERS said:

    I think you can get more for MJD than Just Murray.  Deal MJD because I think his value is as high as it will ever be. Get younger with Murray but get more for him. Don't sell yourself short.



    I agree but if Im forced to make the decision or am drafting in a startup Im taking Murray.



    easy to say and post i guess...but with a 500 dollar entry fee are you still willing to take murray with mjd sitting there?


    Id take Murray ahead of MJD in any dynasty draft. Maybe not redraft. 
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • FarFromHomeFarFromHome
    Posts: 2,050
    and its the beauty of fantasy football...two reasonable people can simply disagree...whats funny is that murray as already 24 years old...ONLY 3 years younger...also recovering from a broken ankle...one more year then its time to dump him to age concerns anyways though :D
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "...and on the 7th day GOD rested....but he created FarFromHome....and he was good..." GEN 14:2

    "I can't believe my American Girl Doll says made in China...that's weird."...My six year old daughter
  • RIPPERSRIPPERS
    Posts: 1,178
    FarFromHome said:

    i guess bottom line is that i cant predict the future...murray may have a better season then mjd this year...i dont doubt that it could happen...im just saying that as of today mjd should land more then murray in my opinion



    I agree but in all formats myself I have downgraded MJD off my map.  So unless MJD was huge value if I had a choice between MJD and Murray I would take MJD only to trade him for Murray or a similar back and more later. MJD shouldn't fall that far in drafts to have to make that decision.
  • JRMRRTJRMRRT
    Posts: 8,509
    Nope...3 years, lol. MJD has some miles on the little guy as well. 
    ________________________________________________________

    DC Nation Forum Moderator
  • TBLTBL
    Posts: 3,509
    I would go with Murray over MJD.  It's close though.
  • footballjunkiefootballjunkie
    Posts: 2,304
    Based on value alone, MJD is your guy.
  • bddavidsonbddavidson
    Posts: 7,387
    how many games has mjd missed in his career two i think murray missed what 6 or so his rookie year..murray is younger and has less miles but he also has trouble staying on the field.. in a startup i take murray redraft mjd and to win a title MJD...
    DC Nation Moderator
  • ReisssoxReisssox
    Posts: 2,410
    bddavidson said:

    how many games has mjd missed in his career two i think murray missed what 6 or so his rookie year..murray is younger and has less miles but he also has trouble staying on the field.. in a startup i take murray redraft mjd and to win a title MJD...


    Well said...
Add a Comment