0-8 couple offers

Took Marshall off the trade block as i couldn't get value for him, then more offers came don't think i like either but not sure i want to keep BM during rebuilding..

2qb dyno, 3rbs 4wrs 2tes non ppr(.25 ppr in 2015 & .5 in 2016)
RBs are CRAP(spiller, miller, Wilson, ball, Lattimore)
If I lose Marshall i still have Torrey, Gordon, Hilton, Harvin.. Tompkins, hartline, drew Davis
i don't have my first, i do have 2 late ones

Offer 1: Marshall for Vereen/2014 1st & 2nd(late)
He has 2 other 1st(both should be top 3) which would be nice with the qbs coming out, but i don't see him giving one of those unless i added something.. Not sure if a top new qb is worth that much..

Offer 2(different guy): Ellington/2014 1st/2015 2nd both likely very late

Not sure i like either but i do need rb.and QB help I start Wilson & Eli. Marshall does have injury problems and there is the slight chance His BFF Cutler doesn't get re signed..

Thoughts?

If I was trading Marshall I would want one of the top 3 picks and vereen marshall is still elite..

You are being low balled, stay strong and hold. Even if you are rebuilding, Marshall is a great building block.

bddavidson said:

If I was trading Marshall I would want one of the top 3 picks and vereen marshall is still elite..

That's my thought, problem is no one in my league will pay that.. I don't understand... If I hold him, he just rots on my team as I lose

U trade Marshall for any of those offers you'll be 0-8 next year also...lol

FarFromHome said:

U trade Marshall for any of those offers you'll be 0-8 next year also...lol

Ha lets hope not.. only thing is, in 2qb leagues picks have a bit more value if i can Get a top rookie QB...

But yes i agree with you guys, I've just gotten so many bad offers its making me wonder if I'm valuing him to high

LukeB5301 said:

FarFromHome said:

U trade Marshall for any of those offers you'll be 0-8 next year also...lol

Ha lets hope not.. only thing is, in 2qb leagues picks have a bit more value if i can Get a top rookie QB...

But yes i agree with you guys, I've just gotten so many bad offers its making me wonder if I'm valuing him to high

Love Manuel, but how much of a difference has he made this season so far?

garyzab said:

LukeB5301 said:

FarFromHome said:

U trade Marshall for any of those offers you'll be 0-8 next year also...lol

Ha lets hope not.. only thing is, in 2qb leagues picks have a bit more value if i can Get a top rookie QB...

But yes i agree with you guys, I've just gotten so many bad offers its making me wonder if I'm valuing him to high

Love Manuel, but how much of a difference has he made this season so far?

Its not about the first year its about the possible 15 years with them, qbs are gold in 2qb leagues.. That said, i don't love Manuel and the qbs this year are much better then him.

i don't think you're valuing him too high, but marshal is getting outscored by Jeffrey which is likely lowering his value. Maybe he gets back on track with McGown as backup qbs tend to force feed their elite studs. i'd hold out a few weeks. I don't think Jeffrey will have good rapport with the backup and Marshall can come back to elite scoring.

Got offered lynch or foster + 2nd for him.. Don't Want foster, wouldn't mind lynch but he's already 27 for a rb with a pending suspension... But does help my rb situation........ Thoughts?

With your wr depth these two new options sound a lot better...

i love Lynch and a 2nd for Marshall. Actually surprised someone offered you that

fontaines said:

i love Lynch and a 2nd for Marshall. Actually surprised someone offered you that

Me too problem is, lynch is no young buck himself.. What's he got, 1.. Maybe 2 more good years... Does that really help me long term?

I think marshall helps you more longterm he is 29 and I see aleast another 3 years of elite production.as lynch maybe 1 to 2 years

LukeB5301 said:

fontaines said:

i love Lynch and a 2nd for Marshall. Actually surprised someone offered you that

Me too problem is, lynch is no young buck himself.. What's he got, 1.. Maybe 2 more good years... Does that really help me long term?

how far out you planning?...lol...I get the people like to be young and dump older players blah blah blah...but marshall is 29 and has at least 3 years of top notch #1 fantasy wr numbers...lynch has a good 2 years of top notch production...I guess Im not the guy who gives up the now for 3 plus years from now...I could die and miss out on wins....
:D

FarFromHome said:

LukeB5301 said:

fontaines said:

i love Lynch and a 2nd for Marshall. Actually surprised someone offered you that

Me too problem is, lynch is no young buck himself.. What's he got, 1.. Maybe 2 more good years... Does that really help me long term?

how far out you planning?...lol...I get the people like to be young and dump older players blah blah blah...but marshall is 29 and has at least 3 years of top notch #1 fantasy wr numbers...lynch has a good 2 years of top notch production...I guess Im not the guy who gives up the now for 3 plus years from now...I could die and miss out on wins....
:D

Good question.. I planned in contending this year (that's why i traded away my 1st) then Harvin went down, spiller blew chunks, Wilson & Miller busted & Eli flopped..

If next year spiller can come around and Wilson miller or ball pan out all i need is another QB & RB..

But that's a lot of ifs

I think your core is very sound luke...and although there is a bunch of "ifs" I still like your chances NEXT year....I wouldn't give marshall away for that crap you mentioned in the beginning...but for lynch and a pick with your roster it sure makes some sense...torrey...Gordon...Hilton...harvin....that's not to bad if you move marshall...lynch would anchor your rbs and relieve some of the pressure spiller has on the success of your team...

I think I would keep Marshall. I kinda like the Vereen, 1,2 offer. Make it 2 firsts & I would do it.

TheHuddle said:

I think I would keep Marshall. I kinda like the Vereen, 1,2 offer. Make it 2 firsts & I would do it.

Ha i tried vereen and the 1.2 or 1.3 & he said no so ill pass with him

Lynch owner is at lynch + 2.1-2.3(10 tm league so tech its like a late 1st.. 1.12) not sure i want to do it but don't know how else I'm going to get some rbs

Ray rice and pierce

LukeB5301 said:

Ray rice and pierce

straight up for marshall?....with your roster I like it...get er done

Howdy, Stranger!

Categories

In this Discussion

Top Posters

Who's Online (10)